Theater Update: A riveting Laurie Metcalf in ‘Little Bear Ridge Road’
How to pronounce Godot; Paddington; theater as church
Theater Update
November 5, 2025

Dear Theater Fans,

Alissa Wilkinson, one of our movie critics, reached out to me this summer, curious about the return of Heather Christian’s “Oratorio for Living Things” and the staging this fall of a number of Off Broadway shows with church-adjacent themes. After seeing most of these productions — including “Nothing Can Take You From the Hand of God” and “Oh Happy Day!” — Alissa has written about a theme these shows have in common: You can walk away from the church, but the songs stay with you.

Samuel Beckett was famously strict about how “Waiting for Godot” and his other works should be staged, but he never stipulated what Godot represented or even how the name should be pronounced. Enter Alexis Soloski, who, along with Josephine Sedgwick, delivered a fun overview of the many ways to say Godot.

While “Waiting for Godot” is getting its fourth Broadway revival, the playwright Samuel D. Hunter is making his Broadway debut with “Little Bear Ridge Road.” In her review, Laura Collins-Hughes called it a “keen-eyed, compassionate” play that marks the “glorious” return of Laurie Metcalf, who is playing “one of the funniest and most thoroughly human characters seen lately on a New York stage.”

Elisabeth Vincentelli raved about New York City Center’s revival of “Bat Boy,” starring Taylor Trensch, and wrote about three plays focused on Jewish identity. Taken individually, “Hannah Senesh,” “Jewish Plot” and “Playing Shylock” are “frustrating, sometimes perplexingly so, pieces of theater,” she wrote in her critic’s notebook. “But taken together they offer a composite look at concerns over Jewish identity and issues of stereotyping and art.”

Please reach out to me at theaterfeedback@nytimes.com with suggestions for stories or to offer your thoughts about our coverage. And urge your friends to subscribe to this newsletter.

Have a wonderful week,
Nicole Herrington
Theater Editor

Like this email?

Forward it to your friends, and let them know they can sign up here.

NEWS AND FEATURES

Two photos are placed side by side. The one on the left shows a woman wearing glasses, strumming a guitar and singing into a microphone. On the left, a woman in a black dress is posing for the camera.

From left: Mandel Ngan/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images; Michael Loccisano/Getty Images

‘Girl, Interrupted,’ With Aimee Mann Songs, to Be Staged in New York

The Public Theater will present the play, which Martyna Majok adapted from the best-selling memoir.

By Michael Paulson

Four dancers rehearsing on a ruby red carpet. One stands, holding his arm out. The other three are in a clump on the floor.

Elias Williams for The New York Times

A Choreographer Chooses the Audacity of Optimism

For her new work, opening at BAM Fisher, Juliana F. May looks to early influences to create her version of a postmodern musical.

By Gia Kourlas and Elias Williams

Paddington Bear stands in a mountainous landscape with animals grazing nearby.

Sony Pictures

London’s West End Will Now Look After This Bear

Over nearly seven decades Paddington Bear has enjoyed a lasting popularity. Now, he’s the star of a new musical.

By Claire Moses

A portrait of Ted Huffman, wearing a black hoodie and seen from the shoulder up, against a white background.

Lea Meienberg for The New York Times

Ted Huffman, Director and Writer, to Lead Major Opera Festival

The Aix-en-Provence Festival in France has named Huffman to succeed the visionary Pierre Audi, who died earlier this year.

By Adam Nagourney

FROM THE CRITICS

In a production image, a woman wearing blue denim sits with her hands clasped in front of her legs. The image of her face is projected onto screens behind her.

Sara Krulwich/The New York Times

Critic’s Notebook

Has Theater Become Everybody’s Church?

New shows by Jen Tullock, Jordan E. Cooper and others have a common theme: You can walk away from the church, but the songs stay with you.

By Alissa Wilkinson

In a production image, Laurie Metcalf, who is wearing a white fleece and gray pants, holds up her hand in front of the face of Micah Stock during an argument.

Sara Krulwich/The New York Times

Critic’s Pick

Laurie Metcalf Is Riveting in ‘Little Bear Ridge Road’

The playwright Samuel D. Hunter makes his Broadway debut with an addition to his Idaho oeuvre, set during the Covid-19 pandemic and its aftermath.

By Laura Collins-Hughes

In a production image, a woman in a beige outfit is sitting with her eyes closed and  her arms wrapped around her knees as she pulls her legs close to her chest.

Tricia Baron

Critic’s Notebook

3 Plays About Jewish Identity That Resist Easy Answers

The Off Broadway shows “Hannah Senesh,” “Jewish Plot” and “Playing Shylock” take stock of discussions around casting and storytelling.

By Elisabeth Vincentelli

Four well-dressed white men holding bottles and arguing next to a silver credenza in a high-rise apartment.

Richard Termine for The New York Times

‘Messy White Gays’ Review: A Satire We’ve Seen Before

Drew Droege’s newest play Off Broadway is a lot like his others, skewering the entitlement of wealthy, oblivious gay men in Manhattan.

By Elisabeth Vincentelli

A man with pointy bat ears and a woman, seated together in a living room gesture giddily.

Richard Termine for The New York Times

Critic’s Pick

‘Bat Boy: The Musical’ Review: He’s Just Trying to Fit In

For its gala, New York City Center revives an antic show about a half-man tabloid sensation, with catchy music and lyrics by the versatile Laurence O’Keefe.

By Elisabeth Vincentelli

In a production image, Stephen Kunken is wearing a white collared shirt and tie and holding up an old-school cellphone while Natalie Gold, in a purple shirt and jeans, stands behind him.

Richard Termine for The New York Times

Theater Review

In ‘Kyoto,’ Seeking to Save the Earth but Veering Off Course

At Lincoln Center Theater, a new play from the makers of “The Jungle” tries to dramatize the negotiations that led to the Kyoto Protocol.

By Laura Collins-Hughes

Two women in festive dresses stand onstage with racks of clothes on either side of them.

Sara Krulwich/The New York Times

‘Romy & Michele: The Musical’ Review: Just Following the Script

This movie adaptation has a couple of laughs, but could have been better served by expanding its reach.

By Elisabeth Vincentelli