Recruiting Sia, a minor-league baseball team, and a real hot-sauce company.
 

APRIL 7, 2026

 

BACKSTORIES

‘Every Day Turns Out to Be the Most Stressful Day You’ve Ever Had’ How the Jury Duty team recruited Sia, a minor-league baseball team, and a real hot-sauce company to pull off the ruse of Company Retreat.

By Angelina Mazza

The Jury Duty team recruited Sia, a minor-league baseball team, and a real hot-sauce company to pull off the ruse of Company Retreat for hero Anthony Norman (right). Photo: Prime

David Bernad doesn’t take kindly to the suggestion that Jury Duty, the documentary-style comedy he produces for Prime Video, is based on a fake premise. Since the series returned in March, he’s seen it again and again: viewers on social media insisting the elaborate experiment, in which an unsuspecting participant is surrounded by actors performing scripted antics, must be staged — that the “unsuspecting participant” is in on the game. “These actors rehearse for weeks upon weeks, and they’re fully committed,” he says. “They’re doing a live theater performance.” Every interaction and plot twist in Jury Duty is carefully orchestrated to steer its unwitting star through a series of low-stakes moral dilemmas while hidden cameras capture his reactions. By the finale, the ruse is revealed, and the star walks away with prize money and a behind-the-scenes tour of The Truman Show–esque operation. Bernad calls fan speculation that the show’s lead role might be fake “deeply offensive.”

READ MORE

Subscribe now to get unlimited access to everything New York, including subscriber-only newsletters, exclusive perks, the New York app, and more.

Subscribe Now
 

News Feed

Celebrity gossip, industry updates, and beyond.

➼ Amanda Batula and West Wilson are seen together In the City. 

➼ Is there something going on between Olivia Wilde and Seth Rogen and Penélope Cruz and Edward Norton in Wilde's new film? 

 

ADVERTISER CONTENT

 
Learn more about OpenWeb
 

Today in Culture

 

Alana Haim’s Rachel Might Be the Secret Villain of The Drama

As the maid of honor, Haim plays her turn from cheerful bud to sanctimonious hater perfectly.

Alana Haim’s Rachel Might Be the Secret Villain of <em>The Drama</em>

 

Ogilvie Originally Had a Much-Different Ending on The Pitt

“There was this confrontation scene with Robby,” says actor Lucas Iverson.

Ogilvie Originally Had a Much-Different Ending on <em>The Pitt</em>

 

What Is Going on With Ye’s Canceled British Shows?

Wireless Festival was completely shut down after Ye was barred from entering the U.K.

What Is Going on With Ye’s Canceled British Shows?

 

What Phil Rosenthal Watches (and Eats) With His Kids

The Somebody Feed Phil star and his daughter, Lily, now write children’s books about trying new things.

What Phil Rosenthal Watches (and Eats) With His Kids
 

ADVERTISER CONTENT

 
Learn more about OpenWeb
 

Latest TV Recaps

  • Top Chef Recap: Improv Interpretation
  • Below Deck Down Under Recap: Enemies to Enemies
  • The Comeback Recap: Death Hurts
  • Rooster Recap: Life and Beth
 

Vulture Games

Play the latest Cinematrix and crossword. 

CINEMATRIX

Cinematrix No. 742: April 7, 2026

Can you name a Sandra Bullock movie that made $100 million?

Cinematrix No. 742: April 7, 2026

VULTURE 10X10

The Golden Head Puzzle