The Book Review: A fresh look at Strega Nona’s sidekick
Plus: the Book Review’s first-ever challenge.
Books

April 25, 2025

This illustration from "Strega Nona" shows the title character greeting Big Anthony in her cottage as a goat, a rabbit and a bird look on.
Strega Nona knows when to ask for help. Big Anthony heeds her call. Tomie dePaola

Dear readers,

Time to shave the Parmesan and sauce the linguine: “Strega Nona,” Tomie DePaola’s charming and glutenous story about a magical, pasta-generating grandma, is barreling toward its 50th anniversary.

You’d be forgiven for losing track of how long Strega Nona has been part of our consciousness, and not just because every other member of the Park Slope Food Coop dresses as if they’ve ransacked her closet. She and her cauldron brimming with noodles have felt like classics for so long that they seem to exist outside time itself.

With this milestone in mind, my colleague Elisabeth Egan revisited Strega Nona’s world and zeroed in on her hapless employee, Big Anthony, and reports that he’s overdue for some justice: In the book, he’s the one who caused the pasta pot to flood the town. It seems, based on other books that dePaola wrote, that Anthony was stuck in a pattern of being scapegoated long before he crossed into Strega Nona’s home.

There are some subtle lessons to be found. Anthony confesses that “everything in my head is fuzzy” when criticized for his tendency to daydream. And he has a history of learning things the hard way. (See the horde of women driven mad by his tarantella-dancing skills in “Big Anthony and the Magic Ring.”)

I wish I could pinpoint my feelings about Anthony when I first read about his plight years ago. I’d like to think I felt compassion for him, and wasn’t on the side of the villagers calling for him to be strung up for his “crime.” Sometimes it takes a kid’s point of view to remember who we really should be rooting for. Not all heroes carry wooden spoons.

Realistically, I was probably more focused on which of my grandmothers could provide me with rivers of spaghetti on demand.

Before I go: Next week, to close out National Poetry Month, the Book Review is unrolling its first-ever challenge. Since you already receive this newsletter, you’ll be among the first to find out about it on Monday. We hope you follow along!

See you then.

This illustration from "Strega Nona" shows the title character greeting Big Anthony in her cottage as a goat, a rabbit and a bird look on.

Tomie dePaola

Essay

I’ve Read ‘Strega Nona’ 100 Times. Now I Feel Sorry for Her Sidekick.

As Tomie dePaola’s classic approaches a milestone birthday, Big Anthony is long overdue for a bit of sympathy.

By Elisabeth Egan

Like this email?
Sign-up here or forward it to your friends. Have a suggestion or two on how we can improve it? Let us know at newsletters@nytimes.com. Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

LOOKING FOR YOUR NEXT BOOK TO READ?

This is the cover of “Crumb” by Dan Nadel

Editors’ Choice

7 New Books We Recommend This Week

Suggested reading from critics and editors at The New York Times.

This image shows a person holding up a copy of the book “The Safekeep,” by Yael van der Wouden, in front of a wall of vines.

Book Club: Read ‘The Safekeep,’ by Yael van der Wouden, With the Book Review

In May, the Book Review Book Club will read and discuss “The Safekeep,” Yael van der Wouden’s novel about a woman wrapped up in a historical drama and a forbidden romance.

By MJ Franklin

The illustrations shows a round, black-and-white photo of Emily Henry surrounded by slivers of six colorful book covers, on a white background.

Everything You Need to Know About Emily Henry

Her best-selling romances have made her a new standard-bearer of the genre.

By Joumana Khatib

Let Us Help You Find Your Next Book: Fantasy

Whether you're looking for a classic or the latest and greatest, start here.

By The New York Times Books Staff

We hope you’ve enjoyed this newsletter, which is made possible through subscriber support. Subscribe to The New York Times.

THIS WEEK IN THE BOOK REVIEW

THE BOOK REVIEW PODCAST

Four books, one yellow, one orange, one brown and one blue, standing, each separate from the others, on a light yellow surface against a darker yellow wall. "The Book Review" is written in white on the top left, and a "T" logo for the The New York Times is on the bottom.

The Book Review

Book Club: Let’s Talk About Adam Ross’s ‘Playworld’

This off-kilter coming-of-age novel about one boy growing up in New York in the 1980s is detailed, digressive and capable of tracking the most minute shifts in emotional weather.

play button

45 MIN LISTEN

ETC.

This is an illustration of Rick Atkinson.

Rebecca Clarke

By the Book

Rick Atkinson Doesn’t Want to Stand on a Soapbox

Being a storyteller is just fine with the journalist turned historian. “The Fate of the Day,” the second volume in his American Revolution trilogy, is out this month.

Article Image

Ben Hickey

Do You Know These Books That Became Disaster Movies?

Many blockbuster films were inspired by literature and this short quiz tests your knowledge about five of them.

By J. D. Biersdorfer

The illustration shows portions of seven book covers and one black-and-white author photo on a peach background.

The New York Times

The Best Forced Proximity Romance Novels

The romance author Beth O’Leary recommends books that show off the trope at its best — playful, knowing, original and deliciously satisfying.

By Beth O’Leary

RECOMMENDATIONS FROM OUR COLUMNISTS

This illustration shows a hand holding a teapot, pouring tea into a cup.

Criminally Good New Murder Mysteries

Our columnist on the month’s best releases.

By Sarah Weinman

In this illustration, an enormous white cloud shaped like a human head drips rain — or tears — on the buildings below,

Thrillers Suffused With a Dark Sense of Dread

Our critic on the month’s best releases.

By Sarah Lyall

BEST SELLERS