Todd Khozein, CEO of global climate and social advisory firm SecondMuse, on the end of Biden’s Inflation Reduction Act The new budget bill makes dramatic changes, essentially ending the IRA. How do you assess the change? We gave American innovation a fighting shot with the IRA and the Bipartisan Infrastructure. And we saw extraordinary progress, like the number of entrants into the long-duration energy storage field, the amount of investment that was going on, the investor enthusiasm, the coordination between grants from either the Department of Energy or the National Science Foundation. This really gave the U.S. a shot to take a major share of the $270 trillion global climate transition. There's a major economic opportunity that the biggest economies in the world are all going after, and it feels like America is bowing out of it. I think it's tragic because that's jobs. I feel like we've lost our way a little bit. We've gotten so focused on beating the other side politically that we've forgotten about this country. There's this extraordinary promise of America, that a bunch of people from a bunch of different places, where all of us are immigrants except for the indigenous communities here, have all been able to come together and build something pretty extraordinary. We've kind of lost sight of that and gotten so wrapped up into one-upping things. We've forgotten that the way that you build things is by people working together. We don't need so much heat. Just tone it down. Let's work together and build something extraordinary. I think that we were on a path to doing that. Now it feels like taking a backseat. What are the international implications? Nobody's going to be cheering louder than China. This is a global market that we're choosing not to participate in. So we're not going to define it and we're not going to be able to have a seat at the table in the way we did before. The tragedy of this is that you have extraordinary American innovators that went to really good schools and are doing really well, and some of the most brilliant scientists. We've lost the thread of what makes an economy great, what makes a country strong, what makes a society vibrant. I feel like this is a sign of where we've effectively dismantled something and haven't really put anything else in its place with this bill which, in my opinion, is tragic.
Do you see reasons to be optimistic about how the U.S. cleantech sector can contend with the shift in federal policy? What I think is hopeful and what I see is 10 years ago there was effectively no climate tech market in New York. … We had a really clear state government leader and leadership that said, “this is our strategy and we're going to build this.” There was clear legislation, the Climate Leadership And Community Protection Act, the legislation said we're going to become leaders in climate tech. And when you go to New York Climate Week, New York has become one of the leading hubs of climate technology in the world. It was because we did things. So I feel like this is actually a really empowering story because it means that all you need is a consistent and sustained strategy. If you have a consistent and sustained strategy from a government level and you have some mechanism to get people to come together, figure out what people's problems are and then target new legislation around the problems that are getting in the way of real entrepreneurs in a real way, this can happen at a local level. This can happen at the state level. If you do that, you will succeed. Did we rely on federal support to help the rest of our business? 100%. Did a lot of our entrepreneurs receive non-dilutive capital? 100%. But we got $430 million in the last two and a half years of private sector capital investing in these businesses. This was because of state mandates. The city and all of its real estate and all of its buildings use new climate technologies to make climate targets. You can do so much at the state level. That may be the thread of hope. |