What Pete Hegseth doesn’t understand about soldiers, by Mike Nelson
Today’s must-read: Lethality alone doesn’t win wars.

One Story to Read Today highlights a single newly published—or newly relevant—Atlantic story that’s worth your time.

Pete Hegseth thinks that America’s armed forces need to choose between lethality and professionalism, Mike Nelson writes. But being a soldier is about more than being a warrior.

(Illustration by Tyler Comrie. Source: Omar Havana / Getty.)

In the summer of 2014, I was leading a company of Green Berets—from the 5th Special Forces Group—in Afghanistan’s Kunduz province. President Barack Obama had recently promised an end of combat operations in the country, and the Taliban understood the tactical implications of his statement, believing that the drawdown of coalition forces meant they could now operate with impunity. They further believed that during the holy month of Ramadan, our Afghan partners, too tired from fasting during the day, would not conduct large-scale operations against them. My company, along with commandos from Afghanistan’s 5th Special Operations Kandak, decided to surprise them …

That night’s events tell two stories. The first is that my team needed to destroy the enemy, using quick and lethal violence. This imperative is the core rationale for any army’s existence. But my team members also needed to act as professional soldiers: to set aside their emotional impulses, even in moments of fear, and uphold the law and the moral standards of the United States Army.


Previous One Story picks:

Sign up for This Week, our editors’ Sunday-evening selection of stories that are sparking conversation right now.

Did someone forward you this newsletter? Sign up here. For full access to our journalism, subscribe to The Atlantic.

Introducing The Atlantic Games

Enter a digital parlor of puzzles and play. You’ll find a collection of brand-new and beloved games that will challenge your intellect and expand your mind.

Play Now

This email was sent to np3s41qlj@niepodam.pl
You've signed up to receive newsletters from The Atlantic.

If you wish to unsubscribe from The Atlantic newsletters, click here.

To update your email preferences, click here.

The Atlantic Monthly Group LLC · 610 Water Street, SW · Washington, DC 20024