Create an Environment for Constructive Disagreement. Yesterday we shared strategies for how to use language in disagreements. If you want people to share bold ideas and challenge assumptions, you also need to create the right environment for it. Here’s how. Train for verbal skill, not just mindset. Instead of instructing people to be open minded or empathetic, show them how to say things that actually convey those traits.

Read online 

Manage email preferences

Harvard Business Review | The Management Tip of the Day
 

Today’s Tip

Create an Environment for Constructive Disagreement

Yesterday we shared strategies for how to use language in disagreements. If you want people to share bold ideas and challenge assumptions, you also need to create the right environment for it. Here’s how.  
 
Train for verbal skill, not just mindset. Instead of instructing people to be open minded or empathetic, show them how to say things that actually convey those traits. For example, replace “be more curious” with “I’m curious how you see this.” Storytelling, hedging, and acknowledgment are teachable, repeatable skills that make disagreements productive. 

Model what good looks like. Leaders should demonstrate these behaviors regularly—in meetings, performance reviews, and one-on-ones. When employees see respectful disagreement in action, they’re more likely to mirror it. This is especially true when leaders use receptive language even under pressure. 

Use technology to support change. Digital platforms create new opportunities to coach in real time. From pre-meeting prompts to AI-powered feedback dashboards, there are scalable ways to help people reflect on and improve their language. Even simulated disagreements with chatbots can provide low-stakes practice. 

Make hiring and promotions a filter. Treat constructive disagreement like any other core skill. Ask candidates how they’ve handled past conflicts, assess how they communicate in moments of friction, and reward employees who demonstrate the skill. 

 

Read more in the article

A Smarter Way to Disagree

by Hanne K. Collins, et al.

Read more in the article

A Smarter Way to Disagree

by Hanne K. Collins, et al.

 

ADVERTISEMENT

 

A laptop displaying the HBR subscriptions webpage.

All access, your way

Digital, print, or both—the choice is yours. Every plan gives you unlimited access to articles, archives, and analysis leaders rely on.

See subscription options

 
Harvard Business Review

Harvard Business Review Virtual Event

Future of Business 2025

Join us Monday, November 3. Featuring leaders from Walmart, Mars Inc., Flagship Pioneering, and more.

Register now
 

Press Play: Why Every Company Needs a Gaming Strategy

Press Play: Why Every Company Needs a Gaming Strategy

by Bastian Bergmann

Learn more

Don’t forget you’re entitled to 20% off your first purchase*

 

*Use promo code HBRORGREG4.
View details here.

 

 

The HBR App:
Get the best in leadership thinking on-the-go.

Download on the App Store.
Get it on Google Play
 
X IconFacebook Icon Instagram Icon

 

You are receiving this because you registered at hbr.org to receive The Management Tip of the Day emails, or you provided us with your email address.

If you prefer not to receive The Management Tip of the Day emails, please unsubscribe.

You may also