Where to Eat: The best things we ate last month
The first rule of restaurant coverage? Always be eating.
Where to Eat: New York City
October 7, 2025

Afternoon, everyone. (Or does 4 p.m. fall under the evening banner? I welcome your feedback on the issue at wheretoeat@nytimes.com.) Thanks for joining us for another Tuesday edition of “Where to Eat.” Here’s what’s on the agenda:

  • The restaurants team shares our favorite bites of September
  • Tejal Rao reviews Emeril’s (yes, that Emeril) in New Orleans
  • Not one, not two, but three major restaurant openings
  • And what does it actually take to open a restaurant from scratch in New York City?
Syrup is poured onto a stack of pancakes on a plate. A glass of orange juice and a knife and fork are also visible.
The blueberry pancakes at Sadelle’s belong in a class of their own. Major Food Group

What we ate (and absolutely loved) in September

The first rule of restaurant coverage: A.B.E. Always be eating. That also means not every meal we enjoy throughout the month makes its way into a review or a “Where to Eat” dispatch. So, I asked some of the Food desk’s team to share their favorite bites of September, most of which were enjoyed right here in New York City.

The wedge salad at Keens Steakhouse

I went to Keens as background research for my steakhouses story and finally understood the appeal of a wedge salad: that blue-cheese funk against the fresh, fresh crunch and the glory of the lardons, all smoke and dark sugars and salt, in mathematically perfected ratios. LIGAYA MISHAN

72 West 36th Street (Sixth Avenue), Midtown

Golfeado at Caracas Bakery

I loved this over-the-top and extremely satisfying version of the Venezuelan yeasted bun: sweet and salty, very gently spiced, drenched in brown sugar syrup and capped with a big slab of soft queso blanco. (And I loved that the server gave me a knife along with it — I needed it.) TEJAL RAO

Multiple locations, Miami

Banana cookie at Tin Building by Jean-Georges

I fancy myself a gourmet grocery store aficionado, and wasn’t feeling particularly inspired by my stroll through the Market, the Tin Building’s sleepy showroom of packaged goods. Luckily, on the way out, a banana cookie caught my eye at the bakery by the exit: The chewy, caramelized-edged poppy seed cookie topped with a glistening knob of bruléed banana was enough to change my tune on the place. BECKY HUGHES

96 South Street (Fulton Street), Financial District

Blueberry pancakes at Sadelle’s

I woke up on a Friday morning last month and decided I really needed a personal day. (If you’ve been thinking of doing the same, take this as your sign.) My sister and I met up at Sadelle’s for brunch, and more than two weeks later we haven’t stopped talking about the incredible pancakes — crispy on the outside, melty and buttery on the inside with jammy blueberries stuffed in the middle. The waffle scales fell from my eyes. NIKITA RICHARDSON

463 West Broadway (Prince Street), SoHo

Chicken biryani at Kebabwala

This is one of the few dishes that could get me into a food hall before noon. Laden with chunks of tender chicken and baked under a crisp, heavily spiced dough shell, it’s easy to see why the limited number of biryani it serves go fast each day. LUKE FORTNEY

124 East 14th Street (Irving Place), inside Time Out Market Union Square

E.J. Lagasse stands in the kitchen at the restaurant Emeril’s. Two dining tables are visible in front of him.
E.J. Lagasse turned his father’s restaurant into a tasting menu spot three years ago — and now he has three stars to go with it. Yuvraj Khanna for The New York Times

THE RESTAURANT REVIEW

Emeril’s

Are restaurant nepo babies a thing? And if so, does Joe Bastianich count? What about Hallie Meyer? Or does the sheer difficulty of operating a successful restaurant make this industry one of the few arenas immune to nepotism? You’ll have to figure that one out while reading Tejal Rao’s review of Emeril’s in New Orleans, which quietly became a high-end tasting menu restaurant three years ago under the culinary vision of the 22-year-old E.J. Lagasse. (The “J” stands for junior.) Read the review

OPENING OF THE WEEK

Wild Cherry

It’s actually a banner week in openings — call it the magic of October. Today, Flynn McGarry’s new California-influenced restaurant, Cove, opens on West Houston Street. In Hudson Yards, the chef Nicolas Lopez is now serving dry-aged rib-eye burgers at Txula Steak inside José Andrés’s Mercado Little Spain. But the banner opening will surely be Wild Cherry, the latest restaurant from Riad Nasr and Lee Hanson (Frenchette, Le Rock, Le Veau d’Or), inside the Cherry Lane Theatre. They’re serving fairly straightforward food — Caesar salad, steak for two, coconut cake — for a restaurant backed by one of the weirder film studios: A24. There’ll also be popcorn to munch on while you catch a showing of whatever talker of a film A24 is screening. More restaurant openings

Mouleena Khan and Aleks Wysoczanska sit at a table in their restaurant. Water bottles, plants and beers are visible.
Over the course of a year, Priya Krishna followed Mouleena Khan, left, and her friend and chef Aleks Jeune as they worked to open a restaurant in Brooklyn. Hiroko Masuike/The New York Times

RESTAURANT LIFE

One year, one restaurant, infinite issues

In the world of daily newspapers, it’s not that often that you get to let a story develop for nearly a year. But Priya Krishna did just that in the form of a colorful interactive article that follows Mouleena Khan, a rookie restaurateur, as she raises funding, applies for permits, creates a menu, hires staff and works late nights to open the restaurant Cheeni in Brooklyn. The story took Priya months to report, but it’ll take you much less time to read. Thanks for joining us and see you on Thursday. Read the story

Have New York City restaurant questions? Send us a note here.

Follow NYT Food on TikTok and NYT Cooking on Instagram, Facebook, YouTube and Pinterest.

If you received this newsletter from someone else, subscribe here.

Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

You received this email because you signed up for Where to Eat: New York City from The New York Times.

To stop receiving Where to Eat: New York City, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings.

Subscribe to The Times

Connect with us on:

facebookxinstagramwhatsapp

Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices

LiveIntent LogoAdChoices Logo

The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018