Movies Update: The Projectionist on “difficult” women and the Oscars.
Plus, “Sinners” and “Wicked: For Good” get an early jump on awards season.
Movies Update
December 19, 2025

Hi, movie fans!

Awards season picked up steam this week with the release of the academy’s shortlists in 12 categories. “Sinners” and “Wicked: For Good” led the way, appearing in eight of the races, including the new best casting competition.

The shortlists — the lineups that voters will winnow down for the actual nominations — largely cover what we call below-the-line contests, like score or makeup and hairstyling. So this week’s news may not be an indication of what will lead the major categories at the Oscars. Indeed, the fact that “One Battle After Another,” which many see as the front-runner, landed only in five categories may not be indicative of anything. (And wow, “Sirat,” the indescribable thriller set in the Moroccan desert, tied with “One Battle.”)

Speaking of what the voters will choose — or not! — our resident Oscars expert, Kyle Buchanan, a.k.a. The Projectionist, wrote about his concern that a few major performances might be overlooked this season simply because the characters are women who buck convention. Rose Byrne (in “If I Had Legs, I’d Kick You”), Jennifer Lawrence (“Die My Love”) and Amanda Seyfried (“The Testament of Ann Lee”) “delivered some of their strongest ever work this year playing difficult women, yet remain on the bubble in most best-actress predictions,” he writes, adding, “Too often during awards season, I find that likability is a metric applied against female leads far more often than to men, who manage to get away with just about anything.” It’s something to keep an eye on next month when the nominations are released.

And we haven’t even talked about the academy’s decision to move the Oscars to YouTube starting in 2029, ending after more than 50 years on ABC. It’s not unprecedented. Other movie-related ceremonies, like the SAG Awards — er, now they’re the Actor Awards — have jumped to streaming and, to my mind, the loss of commercials has improved the entertainment value. There’s also something to be said for showing the biggest awards in Hollywood on the biggest streaming service. But three years is a long time to wait given the pace of technological change, and the landscape may look a lot different when the academy actually makes the leap.

Until then, enjoy the movies!

CRITICS’ PICKS

A man with gray hair and glasses sifting through papers at his desk.

Netflix

critic’s pick

‘Cover-Up’ Review: Seymour Hersh, Scoops and Power

In their documentary, Laura Poitras (“Citizenfour”) and Mark Obenhaus trace the career highs and lows of the famed investigative journalist.

By Manohla Dargis

A man with dark hair and a beard leans against a building, next to a yellow car, under a cloudy sky. He wears a light-colored, short-sleeved shirt.

Neon

Critic’s Pick

‘The Secret Agent’ Review: Carnival in the Face of Carnage

Wagner Moura takes cover in this knockout from the filmmaker Kleber Mendonça Filho that is largely set in 1977 during Brazil’s miliary dictatorship.

By Manohla Dargis

A man and woman in period clothing stand close together in a mossy, dense forest, facing each other among fallen branches and green foliage.

Agata Grzybowska/Focus Features

Critic’s Pick

‘Hamnet’ Review: The Rest Is Silence

Jessie Buckley and Paul Mescal star in a heartbreaking adaptation of the best-selling novel.

By Alissa Wilkinson

REMEMBERING ROB REINER

A man in a baseball hat pointing his finger from behind a camera.

Columbia Pictures, via Everett Collection

An Appraisal

Rob Reiner Gave Us Great Reasons to Go to the Movies

“This Is Spinal Tap,” “When Harry Met Sally …,” “Misery”: Reiner delivered an incredible number of accessible, original and adult movies that we still cherish.

By Manohla Dargis

Article Image

Embassy Pictures

Critic’s Notebook

How Rob Reiner Created His Comedy Legacy

These moments from his movies brought the laughs, in many different ways.

By Jason Zinoman

A young Tom Cruise, wearing a Boston Red Sox cap, stands next to Rob Reiner, wearing a hat with “A Few Good Men” written on it.

Columbia Pictures, via Everett Collection

An Appraisal

Rob Reiner Made Clear What He Believed In, Onscreen and Off

In films like “A Few Good Men,” the director’s ideas of honor and morality were stated as plainly as could be.

By Alissa Wilkinson

Rob Reiner, in 1987, bearded and smiling.

20th Century Fox, via Everett Collection

Rob Reiner: A Life in Pictures

The actor-turned-director spent decades at the forefront of the entertainment world.

By The New York Times

A middle-aged man with a mustache in a light blue T-shirt wearing a green baseball cap.

Shutterstock

Rob Reiner: 14 Movies and Shows to Stream

He played one of the most memorable sitcom roles of the ’70s before going on to direct a string of enduring movie classics. Here are some of his career highlights.

By Esther Zuckerman

MOVIE REVIEWS

A green-tinted photo shows a young Al Pacino looking sweaty and determined next to a bank door.

Netflix

Documentary Lens

‘Breakdown: 1975’ Remembers the Distinctive Cinematic Voices of an Era

This documentary could be better, but it offers a helpful lesson for film fans new to the movies of that decade.

By Alissa Wilkinson

A man holds an image of a girl in focus, close to the camera lens.

WILLA

‘The Voice of Hind Rajab’ Review: When Help Won’t Arrive

Kaouther Ben Hania’s dramatized feature about a Palestinian girl who is killed in Gaza City is both powerfully direct and purposefully removed.

By Ben Kenigsberg

Four cartoon figures stand on a pirate ship.

Paramount Animation/Nickelodeon Movies

‘The SpongeBob Movie: Search for SquarePants’ Review: Underwater Adventure

The latest installment to this entertainment juggernaut relies on a cheap, rote formula and easy gags to keep children engaged.

By Brandon Yu

A young man with curly hair, dressed in ancient-style clothing and sandals, stands on rocky ground at the entrance of a cave, holding a sword by his side.

Angel Studios

‘David’ Review: Preaching to the Choir

The story of David and Goliath is presented as a feel-good family epic in this animated musical released by the popular religious media company Angel Studios.

By Calum Marsh